TddAndConcurrency.Slides.WhenItsQuietBeAfraidVeryAfraid

When It’s Quiet Be Afraid, Very Afraid

Quick Quiz. Is this code MT Safe?

public class ObjectWithValue {
    private int value;
    public void incrementValue() { ++value; }
    public int getValue() { return value; }
}

What’s Happening?

++value is actually three operations:

Read the current value
Add one to it
Store the results

Since a thread can be preempted at any time…

one thread reads the value,
a second thread preempts the first & updates the value,
the first thread continues its work and it has a stale value.

It is actually worse

++value turns into 7 byte-codes. Assume the value field has a value of 42.

Byte-code	Description	Operand Stack After
aload 0	Load local variable 0 onto the stack. In a non-static method, local variable 0 is always the “this” pointer, or the object that received the most recent message.	this
dup	Place a copy of the top operand on the operand stack back onto the operand stack.	this, this
getfield value	Retrieve the field named “value” from the object pointed to on the top of the operand stack, which is “this”. Put the resulting value back on to the top of the operand stack.	this, 42
iconst_1	Put the constant value 1 onto the operand stack.	this, 42, 1
iadd	Perform integer addition on the top two items on the operand stack and place the result back on the operand stack.	this, 43
putfield value	Put the top item on the stack (43) in the “value” field of the object pointed to by the next to top item on the operand stack (this).	«empty»
return	Return back to the place where this method was called.

How Many Possibilities?

Assume the following: Two threads

One instance of ObjectWithValue
Both calling incrementValue()

Answer the following:

How many possible ways can those two threads execute?
What are the possible results?

Answers

How many possible orderings?

3,432

How can we calculate it?

Assuming no looping/branching
All instructions executed through to completion
All threads complete
N = Number of instructions
T = Number of threads

title: TddAndConcurrency.slides.WhenItsQuietBeAfraidVeryAfraid.NumberOfCombinations — (\frac{(N * T)!}{N! ^ T})

</div>

How many possible outcomes?

2
value incremented by 2
value incremented by 1

How?

@Test
public void singleThreaded() throws InterruptedException {
    Thread t = new Thread(incrementValue);
    t.start();
    t.join();
    assertEquals(10000, object.getValue());
}

@Test
public void multipleThreadsFail() throws InterruptedException {
    Thread[] threads = new Thread[5];

    for (int i = 0; i < threads.length; ++i)
        threads[i] = new Thread(incrementValue);

    for (Thread t : threads)  t.start();
    for (Thread t : threads)  t.join();
        
    assertTrue("Expected 10000, actual: " + object.getValue(),
        50000 == object.getValue());
}